Is CAR-NK superior to CAR-T?

On December 15, 2014, Patrick Soon Shiong, the richest physician in the world, acquired 19.9% of Sorrento Therapeutics’ (NASDAQ: SRNE) equity at $5.80 per share (about 41.7 million). Four days later, Sorrento and Conkwest announced an agreement to co-develop CAR-NK immunotherapy. Sorrento’s stock price reached a high of $11.38 on January 15, 2015.

CAR-T cell immunotherapy has been regarded as one of the most compelling breakthroughs in cancer treatment in recent years. Companies working on CAR-T (e.g., JUNO, KITE, BLCM, BLUE, ZIOP) are red hot at present. Sorrento/Conkwest is developing CAR-expressing NK cells rather than T cells to kill cancer cells. How about CAR-TNK compares to CAR-T?

Here is a comparison published in OncoImmunology[1]. The author, Hans Klingemann, is the inventor of the NK-92 cell line and co-founded ZelleRx in 2002, which was renamed Conkwest in 2010. CAR-NK has many several advantages over CAR-T:

(1) CAR-NK cells don’t produce IL-6 which is associated with the cytokine release syndrome. A series of patient deaths in the trials of CAR-T were linked to unusually high levels of IL-6.

(2) CAR-NK cells disappear relatively rapidly from the circulation owing to their limited lifespan. There is no concern about persisting CAR-associated side effects. Whereas Juno Therapeutics has to insert EGFRt gene into the CAR-T cells to control them.

(3) NK cells are known as serial killers which diligently moves from one target to the next one, killing on as many as 7-10 cells.

(4) The transfection efficiency of NK-92 cells is about 50%, even with non-viral methods. Avoiding viral vectors eliminates the risks of oncogene activation and insertional mutagenesis.

(5) CAR-NK cells can also be produced in large scaleunder GMP conditions. Moerover, it may be used in the setting of allogeneic transplantation.

Naturally, only about 10% of circulating lymphocytes are NK cells. The activation of NK cells is determined by the balance of inhibitory and activating receptor stimulation. MHC class I molecules in normal and cancer cells inhibit the activation of NK cells.

Natural NK cells do not express antigen specific receptors. Can CAR-NK cells equipped with an antigen specific receptor kill cancer cells as effectively as CAR-T cells? Hard to say.

Preclinical studies in leukemia, lymphoma, and multiple myeloma have been reported. For instance, treatment with anti-CS1 CAR-NK cells prolonged the survival of multiple myeloma mice from 40 days to 50 days[2].

Sorrento intends to develop anti-CD19, anti-PDL1, anti-PSMA, and anti-CD123 CAR-NK cells. It is expected to initiate Phase I trials in 2016.

[1] Oncoimmunology. 2014, 3, e28147. doi: 10.4161/onci.28147.

[2] Leukemia. 2014, 28(4), 917-927.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s